Your renewal, read line by line.
You know how benefits work, and you may have worked with more than one insurer. We bring an independent second look: the right renewal structure, every line of your renewal from IBNR to insurer fees, and plan design that helps protect the next one.
Pooled, claims rated or ASO. Is yours still the right fit?
Many established companies have only ever been on one renewal structure. There's no headcount that decides it: some groups of around 20 are ready to move off a pool, and some much larger companies are still better off in one. Start with the signs below.
Tap the signs that sound like your business.
There's no score to pass. It's a way to see whether a side-by-side comparison is worth your time.
Book a consultationHow we decide
The renewal structure decides how your costs move.
We settle how your plan should renew before we compare what it costs. For larger groups, that means weighing stability against control, and deciding how much of your own claims experience the business wants to carry.
- 1Renewal structurePooled flex, claims rated, claims rated flex or ASO, and the stop-loss behind it.
- 2Plan designCoverage, employee classes and choices that fit your people.
- 3PriceCompared across a broad range of Canadian carriers.
Renewal Structure Explorer · larger groups
Four renewal structures. The choice matters.
General information only. How each structure works, and whether it suits your business, depends on the insurer, the contract and your group. No renewal structure is right for every employer.
Stop-loss
When one claim is very large, stop-loss steps in.
Stop-loss sets a threshold. When one person's eligible claims pass it in a policy year, the excess is covered through the stop-loss arrangement instead of landing fully on your plan.
The protection is priced into your plan.
Claims below the threshold still count.
A lower threshold means more protection and a higher cost.
Illustration only, not to scale. Thresholds, what counts toward them and whether there's an overall cap depend on the contract.
A claims-rated renewal isn't a guess. Every line can be explained.
The insurer compares what your plan cost with what it expected, adds reserves and charges, then looks ahead. Here's the order, then every line you'll see.
What your group's claims actually cost over the claims period.
Measured against the share of premium the insurer expected to pay out.
Expected cost increases for the year ahead, such as drug prices.
How much weight your own experience gets. Smaller groups get less.
The charge for protection from very large claims.
Plus any changes to plan design or headcount since last year.
Nine lines worth understanding.
Select a line to see what it is, why it moves and what to ask the insurer.
We review each assumption line by line and question the ones that don't fit your group. Insurers will explain their numbers, and many can be discussed.
Target loss ratios, IBNR factors and fees are insurer-specific, so treat any single figure you hear as one insurer's number, not a rule.
On a claims-rated plan, the outgoing insurer pays claims that arrive late from its period; there's no tail for you to pay. On ASO, the business pays those late claims, so plan for the run-off. Either way, ask how the new insurer sets its first-year reserve: a lower quote can simply reflect a different reserve.
Employers typically receive summarized claims information, such as totals by benefit type, not who claimed what. That protects your people while still letting you manage the plan.
Design the plan so one habit doesn't set the renewal.
Small changes in plan design can limit costly or unnecessary use while keeping the coverage your people value. Each one has a trade-off, so we weigh them with you before anything changes.
What's available depends on the insurer and the contract. Changes are best made at renewal and explained to employees before they take effect.
Superior knowledge, excellent attention to detail. I highly recommend Sterling Benefits.
We compare options across a broad range of Canadian carriers.
We settle how your plan should renew before we compare what it costs.
Guided online enrolment, and a secure client portal for your plan administrator.
Based in Kelowna, advising companies across British Columbia and Alberta.
Compare my current plan.
Share your benefits booklet and latest renewal. We'll review how your plan is structured and priced, and whether a different renewal structure is worth comparing, before you renew.
Common questions
Before you move.
How many employees do we need for a claims-rated plan?
There's no set number. Some groups of around 20 are ready to move; some larger companies are still better off in a pool. It depends on your team, your claims history, how much variation you can absorb and what you want the plan to do.
Is a claims-rated plan cheaper than a pooled plan?
Not automatically. In good years it can be; in difficult years it can cost more. You're taking on more of your own risk in exchange for more control.
Can we go back to a pooled plan later?
Sometimes, but it's generally difficult after a major claim. That's why the renewal structure is decided at plan design, not after a bad year.
Is ASO always cheaper?
No. In lighter years it can cost less than an insured plan; in heavier years it can cost more. Stop-loss limits that risk but doesn't remove it.
Does stop-loss mean we're fully protected?
No. It limits the effect of very large individual claims. It doesn't remove cost or guarantee a renewal, and frequent large claims can raise the cost of the protection.
What is IBNR, and do we pay for late claims if we leave?
IBNR means incurred but not reported: claims for services already received that haven't been submitted yet. On a claims-rated plan, the insurer builds a reserve for them into your renewal, and if you leave, the insurer pays the late claims; there's no tail for you to pay. On ASO, the business pays every claim incurred while the plan was in force, including those that arrive after it ends.
What should we pay in insurer fees?
It depends on your group's size, the benefits and the renewal structure. Rather than one percentage, ask for the all-in cost: retention or administration fees, pooling or stop-loss charges and taxes. That makes insurers comparable.
Will we see our employees' health claims?
Typically not. Employers usually receive summarized reports that don't identify individuals.
Next step
Compare the options side by side.
Share your benefits booklet and latest renewal, and we'll compare how your plan is structured and priced before you renew.
Compare my current planA free 30-minute phone call about your team, your current plan and what you want from your next renewal.
Book a Business Benefits consultationSmaller team? See small business benefits →
General information to help you think it through. Personal advice starts with a conversation.