Renewals guide · 05 of 05BC & Alberta

Should I switch insurers for a lower quote?

A lower quote is worth investigating. But the cheapest price isn’t always the best arrangement. Compare the coverage line by line, check how it renews, and protect anyone mid-claim before you switch.

A leadership team comparing plan options around a table
Questions this page answersShould I switch providers if another insurer offers a lower quote?How do I compare group benefits quotes?Will employees lose coverage if we change insurers?
  • IndependentNot tied to one insurer
  • 110+business clients
  • Since 2018BC & Alberta
  • 5.0on Google, 17 reviews
01

Quotes are rarely apples to apples

A lower quote may come from tighter drug rules, lower dental maximums, different coinsurance or fewer paramedical benefits. Even identical-looking plans can differ in pricing assumptions and how they renew. And a sharp first-year price doesn’t guarantee a competitive second year. Compare what you’re buying, what employees will receive, and how the plan will behave over time.

Quote comparison

Compare the new quote with your current plan

For each line, mark the new quote as the same, better, less or unknown. We’ll total it up and list what you still need to ask.

Your comparison so far
Same 0Better 0Less 0Unknown 0

This checklist doesn’t declare a winner. It shows where coverage differs and what information is missing. No prices or employee details are entered or saved.

02

Protect employees who are mid-claim

Some employees may be on medication, in ongoing treatment or receiving disability benefits. Before you switch, get in writing how the new insurer will handle:

  • Existing drug approvals: whether they’re recognized, or a new authorization is needed.
  • Ongoing treatment: different limits or practitioner rules may apply.
  • Employees on disability or not actively at work: confirm which insurer is responsible. Never assume an existing claim transfers automatically.
  • Waiting periods and pre-existing conditions: whether time already served is credited.

Switch readiness check

Ready to switch? Check before you cancel.

Tick what you already have in writing. Never cancel the old plan until the new one is confirmed.

03

How an independent review works

  1. 01

    Review your booklet and renewal

    We look at what you have today and what the insurer is proposing.

  2. 02

    Find what’s driving the price

    Claims, pool, trend, pooling and expenses, benefit by benefit.

  3. 03

    Check what employees receive

    Coverage, limits and provisions people rely on.

  4. 04

    Compare designs and structures

    Across a broad range of Canadian insurers, including the five renewal structures.

  5. 05

    Review terms and the transition

    Pricing, contract conditions, and how people mid-claim are protected.

  6. 06

    Decide with the full picture

    Stay and redesign, or switch with a coordinated plan. Your call, with the facts in front of you.

Common questions

Common questions.

Should I switch providers if another insurer offers a lower quote?

Not automatically. Compare coverage, renewal structure, pricing assumptions, administration and contract terms first. Switching makes sense when the whole arrangement is a real improvement.

How do I compare group benefits quotes?

Line by line: drugs, extended health, dental, life and disability, plus deductibles, coinsurance, maximums, renewal terms, service and how existing claims are handled. Total premium alone hides the differences.

Will employees lose coverage if we change insurers?

Not automatically, but the new contract must be checked. Existing drug approvals, ongoing treatment, waiting periods and anyone not actively at work need attention before the change.

What happens to employees on long-term disability when we switch?

Existing claims need special care. The outgoing and incoming insurers’ contracts decide responsibility. Never assume an existing claim transfers to the new insurer.

Why use an independent broker to compare insurers?

An independent brokerage can compare proposals from a broad range of Canadian insurers, highlight coverage differences and explain the renewal structures available, which gives you more to decide on than headline price.

Before you sign the renewal

Know exactly what you’re getting before you switch.

We’re independent, with access to a broad range of Canadian insurers. We’ll compare your plan against the market and show you the differences that matter.

Compare my current plan

Send your booklet and renewal. We'll compare it against the market and send you a plain-English report. No cost, no obligation.

Compare my current plan
Talk with an advisor

A free 30-minute call about your renewal, your team and your options.

Book a Business Benefits consultation

General information to help you think it through. Personal advice starts with a conversation.